Stichting Laka

Publicatie Laka-bibliotheek:
Der Fall Nikitin / The Nikitin Case (2000)

AuteurDeiseroth, Goettling
Datum2000
Classificatie2.34.2.31/01 (RUSLAND - AKB & OPPOSITIE - NIKITIN)
Voorkant

Uit de publicatie:

Preface

by
Dr. Jürgen Kühling
Justice of the Federal Constitutional Court of Germany

The law protects the dark secrets of the powerful, even here in our open society. 
Whoever reveals unlawful or illegitimate actions of official authorities or his 
employer, that are detrimental to the general public, regularly violates his duty not 
to disclose confidential information, and puts himself in the danger to get reprimanded 
or even penalised. The exemption for executive officers is rather narrow: He is only 
allowed to report on criminal actions. In the law of employment (labour law) there is 
also no generally accepted prohibition to reprimand a "whistleblower". The protection 
of state secrets, of official or business secrets by criminal law is far reaching, and 
there also is no well established exemption for illegal actions.
Furthermore, the societal surroundings of the ''whistleblower'' commonly do not take 
his side. His conduct goes for betrayal or even treason, and is regarded as disloyal. 
Deep-rooted ethics of allegiance to the superior or employer, to the office or the 
state blot out principles of enlightened morality that welcome his conduct. Usually 
the ''whistleblower'' receives - if any - sympathy only from abroad. Avoided by his 
friends, persecuted by law… that is the common fate of a person who resolves to 
break secrecy in the interest of peace, in the interest of the environment, or other 
supreme rights or objects of legal protection.

These conditions and this attitude must change. The moral value of legally protected 
rights or objects must be reflected by the law. Whoever puts common interests of the 
society above his professional duties of being loyal to his employer or to his state, 
as Alexander Nikitin has done, must never be prosecuted. That is not only a demand of 
justice, but also an effective principle of legal policy in favour of peace and the 
environment. A ''Whistleblower Act", as it has been recently enacted in the United 
Kingdom, would be a good start.

I congratulate Alexander Nikitin for his acquittal. I do thank him for what he has 
done. May he enjoy the same unreserved appreciation at home, as it is expressed by 
this Whistleblower- Award, donated by the German Chapter of the IALANA, the 
'Vereinigung Deutscher Wissenschaftler' (VDW; Association of German Scientists), 
and the International Network of Engineers and Scientists to Promote and Protect 
Ethical Engagement (INESPE).

Deze publicatie is alleen op papier bij Laka beschikbaar, niet als pdf.
Publicaties zijn te leen of informeer of we een kopie kunnen maken. Soms, als we tijd hebben, lukt dat tegen kostprijs van de kopieën.