Stichting Laka

Publicatie Laka-bibliotheek:
Waste not, want not? UK nuclear waste disposal: a stakeholder perspective (2024)

AuteurB.Pemberton
2-05-4-10-69.pdf
Datumnovember 2024
Classificatie2.05.4.10/69 (GROOT-BRITTANNIË - AFVAL)
Voorkant

Uit de publicatie:

Waste not, want not? UK nuclear waste disposal: a stakeholder perspective
Barry Pemberton,
Academic Editors: Abdel Mohsen Onsy Mohamed and Evan Paleologos
Review Article
Published: 2024-11-14

Abstract
The UK’s nuclear waste disposal strategy was the subject of a recent consultation.
In its response to the comments made, two approaches to nuclear waste disposal 
emerged. Given the potentially catastrophic impact of nuclear waste incidents on 
UK citizens, this paper’s central question examines these proposals to assess 
whether they will meet the needs of the UK’s stakeholders. The challenges that 
these proposals seek to address include a historic lack of progress on waste 
disposal and its financial provision, an increasing and significant legacy of 
waste together with significant forecasts of further waste to be generated, and 
complex and diverse technical requirements concerning nuclear waste extending 
over extraordinary timescales. However, without a disposal solution, nuclear 
waste will continue to be stored in temporary facilities, which includes other 
risks. To overcome these challenges, the proposals seek to bury nuclear waste 
either in deep geological facilities (GDFs) or near-surface facilities. Both 
proposals depend on stakeholder agreement as to their location.
This paper, therefore, assesses stakeholder needs by developing a stakeholder 
analytical lens through which events are viewed in order to assess the likelihood 
of progress. The primary findings of this paper recognise the need to address the 
issue of nuclear waste disposal through effective governance arrangements, given 
the unprecedented challenges faced. The challenges of nuclear waste disposal are 
derived from the environmental impacts of nuclear waste over near-
incomprehensible timescales and, subsequently, the limitations of human knowledge.
Progress made to date on implementing solutions, perhaps with the exception of 
Finland, has been unsurprisingly slow. The reasons for this may well be due to 
stakeholder issues. The nuclear industry’s past, the levels of information 
asymmetry, and a lack of transparency are some of the factors that may characterise
stakeholder relationships. If these relationships fail, this may also lead to a 
failure in site identification. The ability to assure stakeholders that containment
will be effective and that the proposals meet their needs may avoid the spectre of 
a government-imposed paradigm. Given the global nature of the nuclear waste problem, 
the wider implications of this paper may also be of international interest.