Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
Rulemaking on earthquakes and emergency planning (1985)

AuthorHarmon Weiss, Jordan, NRC
DateFebruary 1985
Classification6.01.3.80/10 (NUCLEAR SAFETY - SITE SELECTION / EMERGENCY PLANS)
Front

From the publication:

Union of Concerned Scientists' and Nuclear Information and Resource 
Service's Joint Comments on NRC's Proposal to Bar From Licensing Proceedings 
the Consideration of Earthquake Effects on Emergency Planning

Introduction

The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (''NRC'' or ''Commission'') has published a 
proposed rule that would eliminate from licensing proceedings the consideration of 
earthquake effects on emergency planning. 49 Fed. Reg. 49640, December 21, 1985. 
By this rulemaking, the Commission is apparently attempting to legitimize its 
refusal to consider the issue in licensing hearings for the San Onofre and Diablo 
Canyon nuclear power plants, both of which are potentially subject to high-
acceleration earthquakes.
The Commission's effort to validate in a rulemaking these two arbitrary operating 
license decisions fails utterly. The rulemaking is irrational, and lacks any 
supporting factual record. The Commission supplies no justification for its decision 
to carve out this exception to the fundamental principle that emergency plans must 
anticipate a wide spectrum of accidents that ''might have an impact on public health 
and safety.'' NUREG-0654 at 2. Moreover, the probability of an earthquake-caused 
accident is well within the range of accidents that must be considered in emergency 
plans.

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.