Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
The “Nuclear Energy Paradox”- Investigating nuclear imaginaries in energy projections (2026)

AuthorF.Böse, A.Wimmers, B.Steigerwald, C.von Hirschhausen
6-01-0-20-136.pdf
DateMarch 2026
Classification6.01.0.20/136 (IMPORTANCE WORLDWIDE)
Front

From the publication:

The “Nuclear Energy Paradox”- Investigating nuclear imaginaries in
energy projections
Fanny Böse, Alexander Wimmers, Björn Steigerwald, Christian von Hirschhausen

Received 22 July 2025; Received in revised form 4 February 2026; 
Accepted 19 March 2026
Energy Research & Social Science 135 (2026) 104676
Available online 27 March 2026

ABSTRACT
Current energy projections often envision an expansion of nuclear capacities 
to decarbonize future energy systems. However, this contrasts with the 
historic and current status of the nuclear industry, marked by technoeconomi
 challenges for both light-water and non-light-water reactor technologies. 
Regardless, projections of strong nuclear growth have persisted since the 
1970s. This paper investigates the “nuclear energy paradox” which shows the 
recurring divergence between historical projections and actual developments.
A data compilation of long-term energy projections from international 
organizations such as the IAEA and the IEA as well as energy system models 
like GCAM and MESSAGE, as used in the IPCC, reveal a recurring pattern of 
high-growth projections for nuclear power. Such projections often rest on 
techno-economic assumptions such as substantial cost reductions. We propose 
the concept of nuclear imaginaries to show that these assumptions are embedded
 into techno-economic visions of nuclear power development, which shape model
assumptions and narratives. The historic perspective helps to show that 
nuclear imaginaries may never materialize and remain in a hypothetical state 
for decades. Our findings support decision-makers in making more informed 
decisions and urge for caution when interpreting energy scenarios and 
projections, especially for nuclear power.