Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
The sham(e) that is the BNPP. Briefing Paper on Bataan NPP (1992)

AuthorNetwork Opposed to the BNPP
4-16-0-00-07.pdf
DateAugust 1992*
Classification4.16.0.00/07 (PHILIPPINES)
Front

From the publication:

THE SHAM(E) THAT IS THE BNPP

Including Appendices
The Westinghouse Webb by Jim Donahue
& Findings of the Philippine Government-Commssioned 1990 technical Audit 
of BNPP-1
 

IN 1974, THE PHILIPPINE government asked General Electric (GE) and 
Westinghouse to bid for its nuclear plant project, involving the construction
 of two 600- megawatt nuclear plants. Marcos contracted the engineering firm 
Burns & Roe Enterprises, Inc. as a consultant, which in turn hired Marcos 
crony Herminio Disini as its "special sales representative."
GE sent a 4-volume proposal amounting to $700 million for two plants. 
Westinghouse sent only a brochure and a quotation of $500 million also for the 
two plants. On top of the objections of his own advisers, Marcos warded the 
contract to Westinghouse and accepted the inflated price of $ 1.1 B for a single 
plant.
Westinghouse clinched the deal by bribing Marcos and Disini with at least $17 
million-the figure admitted by Westinghouse in court-and awarding choice 
subcontracts to Disini companies, some of which were formed specifically for 
the project.
The Bataan Nuclear Power Plant (BNPP) finally cost $2.2 billion, including the 
cost of repairs and upgrades required by the Puno Commission in 1979. Of this
 amount, the Philippines still owes the banks $ 1.1 billion, plus interest.
In 1986 the Aquino government mothballed the BNPP in response to strong opposition 
from Bataan residents and a broad cross-section of the citizenry. It filed a 
bribery and annulment of contract suit against Westinghouse and Burns and Roe in
New Jersey. The judge referred the annulment suit to the International Arbitration 
Court in Geneva. The Geneva court ruled that Westinghouse bribed Disini and 
intended to bribe Marcos. But it also ruled that the contract could not be annulled 
since there was insufficient proof Marcos actually received the bribes.
On March 5, 1992, the Aquino government announced it had agreed to negotiate an 
out-of-court settlement proposed by Westinghouse. The presiding judge gave the 
Philippine government and Westinghouse 180 days to agree on the terms of this 
settlement; in which event, the bribery suit would be dropped.
As the September 2,1992 deadline neared, the Ramos government announced it would 
"negotiate for better terms", and formed a new negotiating panel headed by Sen. 
Vicente Paterno.

*) Estimated date