Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
Comments by Non-Government Organizations on AECL's Cernavoda Reactor 2 Environmental Assessment Summary (2002)

Author14 NGOs
-
Date2002
Classification2.29.9.90/02 (ROMANIA - FACILITIES)
Front

From the publication:

NGO Comments on Cernavoda 2 EA Summary by AECL - page 1

1. Executive Summary

These are comments by non-government organizations on the Environmental 
Assessment Summary on the proposed completion of the Cernavoda 2 nuclear 
reactor, released by Canada's state-owned reactor vendor, Atomic Energy of Canada 
Limited (AECL).(1) AECL's main partner is Ansaldo Nucleare, an Italian company 
which is a division of Ansaldo Energia SpA, which is part of Finmeccanica. 
Cernavoda 2 will be owned and operated by Societatea Nationala Nuclearelectrica 
(SNN), Romania's state-owned nuclear company. The organizations which have 
endorsed this submission are listed in section 14.

AECL' s Environmental Assessment Summary concludes that the effects of the 
construction, operation and decommissioning of the Cernavoda 2 reactor will be 
"not significant, unlikely to occur or beneficial under normal operating conditions 
[ ... ] AECL, its partners and SNN are committed to applying mitigative measures 
such that significant adverse environmental effects are not likely to occur." (2) 
However, these claims are not· substantiated by the contents of the environmental 
assessment summary document. The environmental assessment completed by AECL 
is inadequate, and should be redone and subjected to independent review through a 
public hearing process, in order to address numerous deficiencies.

This submission makes 23 specific recommendations for an improved environmental 
assessment, which appear throughout and are listed together in section 13. The Export 
Development Corporation and other financial institutions should not use the current 
AECL environmental assessment for approval of Cernavoda 2 project financing. The 
endorsing organizations do not favour any use of government loans or financing for
nuclear power plant exports, but if such a decision is made, it should be based on a 
properly conducted environmental assessment.

Some of the principal deficiencies in the AECL environmental assessment include:

1. the lack of an adequate public process, including the failure to provide complete
versions of the environmental assessment documents;
2. the failure to consider alternatives to completing Cernavoda reactor 2;
3. the failure to assess the consequences of a catastrophic nuclear accident;
4. the failure to disclose details of the nuclear emergency plan;
5. the failure to conduct an adequate Probabilistic Risk Assessment;

(1). AECL, Cernavoda Unit 2 Nuclear Power Plant, Environmental Assessment
Summary, CES..Q3702-ENA-001, December 2001. Annex 1, Alternatives Study 
Summary. Annex 2, Romanian Public Consultation Process Summary. Annex 3, 
Cernavoda NPP Site Environmental Management Plan Summary. Annex 4, 
Cernavoda NPP Site Quality Assurance Program Summary. Annex 5, Thermal 
Studies of the Danube River and Danube-8/ack Sea canal Summary.

(2). AECL, Environmental Assessment Summary, December 2001, p. 19.

This publication is digitally available in the Laka library, but it's not on-line.
E-mail us (info@laka.org) if you would like the pdf sent to you (with the subject, number and title). Of course you can also come by.