Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
The Sellafield Study; A Study of the Gaseous Tritium & Carbon 14 Emissions from Sellafield and Their Impact on Perinatal Mortality (1998)

AuthorHugh Richards
DateMarch 1998
Classification2.05.8.33/03 (UNITED KINGDOM - SELLAFIELD - RESEARCH (CANCER))
Front

From the publication:

Introduction

0.1 BNF plc are experiencing problems operating the THORP plant at Sellafield and
in November 1996 applied to the Environment Agency for a six-fold increase in 
gaseous discharge limits for tritium (1).

0.2. Overall increases in gaseous discharge limits from the site were proposed of
16% for tritium and 17% for carbon 14.

0.3 In July 1997 BNF withdrew their (November 1996) application, citing
improvements in abatement techniques. They are no longer applying for an 
increase in discharge limits for gaseous tritium, and have reduced the amounts 
of the increases sought for iodine I29 and Cl4.

0.4 There are strong reservations about the ability of BNF to keep within the existing
discharge limits for tritium. The company has admitted that problem has not gone 
away.

0.5 A new 'discharge prediction model' keeps projected discharges from THORP
within the current discharge limits up to March 2001. After that date the fuel to be 
reprocessed will be 'higher burn-up' and shorter cooled, and as a result the current 
'tritium limit will reduce operational flexibility and pose an increased business risk.' 
(2) "In order to address this situation, work is continuing to extend our understanding
of the behaviour of tritium in the THORP process and to evaluate the potential for 
further improvement in its abatement."

0.6 Current compliance with the original gaseous tritium discharge authorisations
is based on being able to keep a very high percentage of the tritium as water. The 
potential exists for future 'unpleasant surprises' as only a very small perturbation 
of this ratio would overwhelm dehumidifiers already close to saturation.

0.7 There is still a great deal of uncertainty about the ability of abatement
techniques to cope with the coming 'higher burn-up' and shorter cooled fuel in 
practice as against theory. The same letter reveals the uncertainty which remains 
behind the variation application for Cl4.
"The chronic WVP discharge of C14 therefore cannot readily be linked to operations 
within the High Level Waste Plants. Further work is now being done to understand 
the source." 

0.8 Compounding the uncertainty about the ability of BNF to keep their discharges
within authorised limits, there is uncertainty about the biological basis of those 
discharge limits.
" ... the mutational damage caused by radiation has two properties of utmost 
significance different from those of most other types of biological damage. The 
first of these is that the dose-response relationship is linear, without any threshold, 
and the second is that doses are strictly cumulative. "(3)

The Sellafield Study - Introduction March 1998

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.