Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
On Site ... Out of Sight?

AuthorNuclear Free Zones Scotland
Date
Classification2.05.4.10/23 (UNITED KINGDOM - WASTE - NIREX/NDA DECOMMISIONING)
Front

From the publication:

In March 1989 a company called United Kingdom Nirex Limited staged a bid to 
find an 'Out of Sight; Out of Mind' solution to the problem of Britain's nuclear waste. 
As a result, Dounreay in Caithness is one of two sites to be investigated with a view 
to dumping nuclear waste deep underground. There are also another 10 undisclosed 
sites, several of which are believed to be in Scotland, which are held in reserve for 
further investigation if necessary.

This leaflet explains the background to waste dumping in the United Kingdom and 
outlines the potential risk to the people of Caithness, the Highlands and Islands and 
Scotland as a whole from the Nirex proposals and is a response to some of the 
points made by Nirex in their publications The Way Forward and Going Forward.

1. INTRODUCTION
Most nuclear waste in the United Kingdom is produced as a result of the generation 
of electricity by nuclear power and the reprocessing of our own and foregoing spent 
nuclear fuel. Much smaller quantities arise from industrial and medical sources. 
Radioactive waste also arises as a result of military activities (including weapons 
production). Without careful and responsible control, all of these wastes could pose 
a serious threat to health and to the environment for a time longer than life itself 
has existed on Earth.

There are two possible approaches to the nuclear waste issue; indefinite storage or 
dumping. Indefinite storage involves careful management of waste in specially 
designed buildings at existing reactor sites. The waste packages would be constantly 
monitored and packages found to be faulty would be removed from store, and 
repackaged before being re-admitted to store. This is the approach favoured by most 
environmental groups and the majority of planning authorities in Scotland. The main 
disadvantage of this system is that it would be the more expensive option, as it 
would require permanent manning and active management for all time.

'Dumping' on the other hand, frequently described as 'disposal' by the nuclear 
industry, would involve digging out underground 'caverns', lowering the waste into 
them and then, when the caverns are full, filling them up with concrete or other 
material, sealing the access tunnels and hoping that all will be well. The main 
advantage is that, despite the high capital cost of digging the caverns, the dump does 
not need to be manned in the long-term, so that it is a less expensive option - the 
Government favours the latter, cheaper approach.

United Kingdom Nirex Limited has been given the job of dealing with solid 
intermediate and low-level nuclear wastes in accordance with government policy of 
the cheaper deep-disposal option. Nirex is a company entirely owned by the nuclear 
industry. 42.5% of the equity is held by British Nuclear Fuels, the company who 
operate the Sellafield plant. Another 42.5% is held by the English Central Electricity 
Generating Board. The remaining 15% is split evenly between the United Kingdom 
Atomic Energy Authority (operators of the Dounreay Establishment) and the South 
of Scotland Electricity Board. The Government holds a 'Golden Share' in Nirex.

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.