Publication Laka-library:
The nuclear controversy (1979)
| Author | Stott, Taylor |
| Date | October 1979 |
| Classification | 2.05.0.00/34 (UNITED KINGDOM - GENERAL) |
| Front | ![]() |
From the publication:
Preface The Windscale Inquiry was the first major examination in public of the nuclear controversy. Although the Inquiry was concerned with outline planning permission for a reprocessing plant designed to handle oxide fuel at a site which already contained a reprocessing plant for 'magnox' fuel, together with various other nuclear installations, the terms of reference of the Inquiry were widened and encompassed many of the issues raised by nuclear power in general. The proceedings were thus expanded and the Inquiry laster for l00 days. The transcript of the proceedings contains more than 2.5 million words in its 8000 pages, and supporting documents run to several hundred references ranging from single sheets to major technical books. It is perhaps not surprising therefore that the report of the Inquiry by Justice Parker does not go into this supporting evidence in any detail. The report does not attempt to represent the evidence of both sides, rather the arguments are briefly summarised and reasons given for the position taken by Parker. Some argument and evidence is not presented at all, in particular that relating to alternative energy supplies. In addition to the brevity of the Report and its omissions, it presents a further obstacle to researchers, in that at no point is it referenced to the daily transcript. We felt at the time of the Inquiry that the information then released by British Nuclear Fuels Ltd. (BNFL), together with the documentation used in evidence, and the arguments of the various parties, constituted an important resource for those active in the nuclear debate and for researchers in science policy, sociology of law, environmental politics and so on. When the Parker Report was published its shortcomings were apparent in this and other respects and we were urged by many to proceed with our projected documentation, which at that time was intended to be a working index of the material. We have thus gone further and produced a guide which both acts as an index to the documentation, and as an account of the issues. We have sought to present the material in a neutral tone and in as objective a way possible. As partial observers and participants we recognise that in some areas we may have fallen short of this ideal. For example, we have accorded more space for detail on matters that we felt were inadequately represented in the Parker Report. However, we have sought to include at least a reference to all significant contributions.
This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.

